Editorial pick7 games

Why we rejected these popular apps for kids

Seven popular apps for kids 2–8 we cannot recommend, ordered worst to best. The thread that runs through every rejection: monetization pressure aimed directly at children, ad density that overrides gameplay, or design patterns that exploit a kid's developmental window. Every claim below cites a real public source — App Store reviews, FTC complaints filed by child advocacy groups, regulatory analysis, news coverage, parent forums, and the developers' own privacy disclosures. We compiled this list because parents Google "is X safe for kids" before they download, and the source-cited research was already sitting in our archive. This is the consolidated answer.

SYBO Games (Copenhagen) — co-developed with Kiloo until 2020; SYBO sole publisher 2020+; acquired by Miniclip July 2022· Ages 5-8

Subway Surfers

Score 39 — the loudest example of the genre on our shelf. ESRB E, but Apple's App Privacy label flags Location, Identifiers, Usage, and Diagnostics in "Data Used to Track You." Common Sense Media gives it a "Warning" privacy rating — "data shared for third-party advertising and collected by tracking services." The 30-second endless-runner loop is harmless on its own; the ad density between runs, the 32 third-party trackers documented in the App Privacy label, and the addiction patterns parents repeatedly flag are the rejection.

Read the review →

Scopely (publisher; originally Kitka Games)· Ages 7-8

Stumble Guys

Score 46 — Fall Guys clone tuned to monetize a six-year-old. The ask is kid-safe physical comedy; the tell is the gem-keyed cosmetic shop that makes every match feel like a sales funnel. Ads cluster between matches, IAP pricing scales aggressively, and the chat layer at higher levels opens stranger contact our 48-of-100 safety score reflects. Common Sense Media age 9+ with consumerism + violence flags.

Read the review →

Kongregate / Disney· Ages 5-6

Where's My Water? 2

Score 48 — Disney's freemium sequel to a beloved $0.99 paid original. Kotaku called the launch energy-meter mechanic "an incredibly player-unfriendly game mechanic" — "like being punished for playing." Disney removed the energy gate in Dec 2013 after sustained backlash, but Pixalate's COPPA manual review documents that the ad load never went away: "advertisements such as Candy Crush Saga start right after entering age verification." Common Sense Media: after level 30, "players are forced to either pay to advance or must ask friends on Facebook for keys."

Read the review →

Roblox Corporation· Ages 7-8

Roblox

Score 52 — not a single game but a UGC platform with millions of player-made experiences, including thousands that violate Roblox's own community standards. Common Sense Media age 13+. The Robux economy ($4.99–$99.99 ladder) gates progression in many top experiences, and the chat layer connects to strangers worldwide. Roblox's Nov 2024 safety updates do not flip this list — they confirm the scale of the problem. Safety subscore 38 is the lowest in the catalog.

Read the review →

$Prodigy Math Game$

Prodigy Education Inc.· Ages 6-8

Prodigy Math Game

Score 53 — the "education" coating sells the platform to schools (90,000+ assign it as homework, per Fairplay for Kids) while the in-game UI relentlessly upsells Premium memberships at ~$120/year to children. Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood and Fairplay filed an FTC complaint in Feb 2021 alleging Prodigy "unfairly manipulates children into asking their parents for a Premium membership" — creating "two classes of students, those whose families can afford a premium membership, and those that cannot." Fairplay's blunter version: "kids without memberships literally walk in dirt while kids with memberships ride around on clouds."

Read the review →

Niantic, Inc. (now Scopely subsidiary)· Ages 5-8

Pokémon GO

Score 58 — a location-based AR game with a privacy footprint Apple's App Privacy label categorizes as "Data Used to Track You: Location, Contacts, Identifiers, Usage, Diagnostics." EPIC argued Niantic's "unlimited collection and indefinite retention of detailed location data" violated COPPA data-minimization. Love146, a recognized anti-trafficking org, documents predator exploitation of Lures with a police officer's quote: "if I'm a bad guy, I know where to sit and wait for your children to arrive." Internet Matters: "Children may unknowingly be exposed to people who may pose a danger to them."

Read the review →

Hipster Whale (Matt Hall & Andy Sum, Melbourne)· Ages 6-7

Crossy Road

Score 59 — the 2014 Apple Design Award winner is genuinely well-designed. The free version's monetization is not. Common Sense Media: "nearly 90 characters to buy," "frequent reminders to purchase, watch." Roughly 70% of revenue is video advertising — meaning the design's incentive gradient rewards more ads, not better play. Crossy Road+ on Apple Arcade ($4.99/mo) ships the same game with no ads or IAP; the free version exists to monetize parent attention to advertisers.

Read the review →